INSTITUTIONAL
S&P: 4,120 ▲PANINI: 105 ▲
STRATEGYDecember 1, 2024 2 min read

The Death of the 60/40 Portfolio

The classic 60/40 stock-bond allocation failed spectacularly in 2022. We examine what killed it, whether it can be resurrected, and what should replace it in a higher-rate regime.

SHARE:

Executive Summary

The 60/40 portfolio—60% stocks, 40% bonds—was the default allocation for balanced investors for decades. It offered diversification, reasonable returns, and downside protection.

Then 2022 happened. Stocks fell 18%. Bonds fell 13%. The negative correlation that made 60/40 work broke down completely.

Was this a temporary anomaly or a permanent regime change?

What Killed 60/40?

The culprit: synchronized inflation shock. When inflation surges, both stocks and bonds fall together because:

  • Bonds fall as yields rise to compensate for inflation
  • Stocks fall as profit margins compress and discount rates increase

This happened in the 1970s and again in 2022. The correlation between stocks and bonds flipped from -0.3 to +0.5.

Can It Be Fixed?

Yes, but it requires modifications:

60/40 2.0:

  • 50% equities (quality bias, lower duration)
  • 30% short-duration bonds (1-5 years)
  • 10% inflation hedges (TIPS, commodities, gold)
  • 10% alternatives (real estate, private credit)

The key insight: duration matters. Long-duration assets (growth stocks, long bonds) are vulnerable to inflation shocks. Shorter duration assets provide better protection.

Historical Context

The 60/40 portfolio worked brilliantly from 1980-2020 because:

  • Inflation fell from 14% to 2% (bond bull market)
  • Interest rates fell from 15% to 0% (multiple expansion)
  • Globalization suppressed costs (profit margin expansion)

None of these tailwinds exist today. We're in a higher-rate, higher-inflation regime that requires different portfolio construction.

The New Allocation

Our recommended balanced portfolio for 2025:

  • 45% equities (overweight value, quality, international)
  • 25% investment-grade bonds (5-7 year duration)
  • 15% real assets (commodities, infrastructure, real estate)
  • 10% cash/T-bills (optionality for opportunities)
  • 5% alternatives (gold, hedge funds, private credit)

This allocation targets 7-9% returns with lower drawdowns than traditional 60/40.


Full report includes backtests, scenario analysis, and implementation guide. Subscribe for complete access.

Want More Insights Like This?

Subscribe to Panini Research for institutional-quality analysis at lunch-money prices.
$12.50/month for unlimited access.